…about waterline eyeliner:
If you do get some fallout below your eye, try smudging it and incorporating it into the whole eye’s makeup. I did that today and it made for a great looking smokey eye with much less fuss overall. It really worked when I put regular waterproof eyeliner on the upper lid. That looks a bit harsh so I went over it with some black powder I usually use on my eyebrows. Eureka! That made me try to experiment with smudging the fallout under my eye and the whole look was very nice. Give it a try.